"Based on the probability that the character Stanley exists, I believe that Stanley is actually Grunkle Stan, who has assumed Stanford Pine's identity since the portal's first opening 30 years ago. Stanford Pines is the true author of the book. The memories and quotes from Grunkle Stan reveals that he's a fraud who travels around and gets imprisoned around a lot. Thus, it's highly improbable that he's been living in Gravity Falls all this time (Time Traveler's Pig). It's also revealed that the house belonged to a scientist, who built secret portals and static-carpets in his house-lab. Thus, it's obvious that the scientist and the author is one and the same. Since the house has always belonged to Stanford Pines, the answer has literally written itself on who the author is. The Shapeshifter also mentioned that the author hasn't been himself in 30 years, which means that Shapeshifter thinks the author is still alive but has changed into a different person. This further improves the possibility that the fraud Stanley stole the scientist and author, Stanford Pines's identity. This might also explain why Bill Cipher thought about an image of a younger Stan when the name Stanford Pines was mentioned. There's no other way to explain how Grunkle Stan came upon the portal, the books, and the secret codes used unless he personally knew the Author. It's also possible that he was the one who betrayed Stanford Pines, as he mentions a certain "He" in his messages. Finally, in the newest trailer for the next episode, the trailer seem to weigh heavily on the Pine twins calling Stan the greatest uncle in the world. If anything, I'd say Stan was getting a guilty conscience for lying to them about being their uncle. Thoughts?" -Submitted by Xian is wut wut in my wut
And I recall seeing the entire thing sometime last year (or possibly even earlier), and if I remember correctly, it was possible ways that the characters were going to be introduced in the pilot? I am not sure. But still: "I'm... I'm probably you're uncle"?
Interpret it how you want... But I think it helps support your theory even more!
My reaction was literally "Oooo... OOOOOOOO!!"
(Also, all of you people submitting have rad names. Like, 10/10)
So your theory behind Grunkle Stan being a fraud is that he is not actually Stanford, but someone else (specifically Stanley) entirely? Dang. That's good man... That's good. (Can you hear how blown my mind is right now)
I love how this theory puts a totally different spin on the whole "fraud" thing, and you have a pretty good amount of evidence to back it up! And it would also explain why he looked guilty in the trailer for Not What He Seems...
Ahh, after reading this I'm even more hyped for the episode!! Xian, if you have anymore theories, make sure to send them in, I would love to hear them! // kimiko hope
P.S. I put this in another response to another submission, but I think it's relevant to this one as well... I found this while on tumblr:
"I saw a small image on the internet the other night suggesting that Carla (from stanford's past) was lil' gideon's mom. It was an interesting thought and I thought you might be able to dive a little deeper. Thanks, hope it isn't too much trouble." -Submitted by willowspirit (GF lovah!)
Gravity Falls lovers unite!
Hi Willow!! Haha, don't worry, it shouldn't be much trouble!
So Carla being Lil Gideon's mom, eh? That's a new one! Let's get into it shall we~
Since I have never heard of this theory before, I looked it up on Google. This led me to a certain tumblr post, which I assume is what you saw (or maybe not? idk this was one of the only ones that came up):
"okay so this is just ONE of my theories and i have a billion not really but you know what i mean.So i’ve read some other ones and gathered a lot of info and i’ve thought a lot about this so here it goes.every body knows about pinescest right?and a lot of people ship it,remember this it’s important.so another headcanon says carla (stans young lover) is gideons mom.another is that she wrote the book and that gideon hypnotized (exuse my 5 year old spelling)her with a spell from the book. in the end of the gideon commercial it says “consult your physicist immediately.Carla,I’ve always loved you but never had the guts to say it.”That might mean that she was hypnotized during the show,but gideons dad didnt know he did it on purpose,so he thought that maybe during a show some one could be mentally scarred or traumitised during it.or maybe gideon used his mom as a apprentice and hypnotized her.any way has any one noticed that young carla’s hair looks a lot like mables?so theres a chance stan and carla might have had a incest relationship like maybe a unmentioned sister or a cousin or maybe possibly a daughter or step daughter or neice,stan does look a little older then her.but after the hippie incident she left.wich might also explain gideons mom because she was supposedly hypnotized.after that he might have died or left possibly because the curse drove her mad and he never lifted it.but wether it was gideon being all sassy and rude or a curse she doesn’t date the hippie anymore.Stan might still love her and gideons dad knows about it and is the reason for there rivalry.he might love carla but carla doesnt love gideons dad back.there is also another headcanon that stan is dipper in the future.wich might be the reason mabel and dipper were sent there so they could be closer so maybe mable wouldnt leave insisting mable is carla wich who is gideons mom.im insane i know.thank you for reading if you didnt leave first because this completely ridiculous.so so silly." -From http://gravity-falls-conspiracies.tumblr.com
To be honest, I am going to ignore the majority of that (because it's kind of weird... specifically the incest part), and put my own spin on this whole shebang.
Bud Gleeful, Gideon's father, is known to have a rivalry with Stan right from the get-go. It is automatically assumed that this is due to their rivaling businesses, "The Mystery Shack" and "The Tent of Telepathy", but who's to say it doesn't go deeper than that?
Commercials for Lil Gideon's Tent of Telepathy is voiced by Bud himself, as you can see here:
"Carla, I've always loved you but never had the guts to say it"? Bud loves a woman named Carla?
Gideon's mother's actual name has never been stated outright in the show, and in canon, is simply "Mrs. Gleeful". This is even shown in the episode Society of the Blindeye, where she was one of the many citizens in Gravity Falls to have her memories taken away:
Knowing that, I want to bring your attention to the ending of the longer commercial (which can't be found anywhere on YouTube, by the way. Seriously?). During this commercial, Bud does the thing where he speaks really fast and the text goes through the screen quickly as well, to match the pace of the sped-up voice. The most notable thing is the last part he says:
So what am I getting at? Her first name could totally be Carla! Last names aren't an issue here, since traditionally, the wife takes on the husband's last name when they are married.
But speaking of the Society of the Blindeye... Do you remember how McGucket was like before the effects of the memory ray took a toll on him?
Now he has went insane, and his overall appearance is rougher, and less clean.
...Similar to how Mrs. Gleeful looks.
At these points, McGucket is not only acting sane, but his appearance is of the norm as well. This is in contrast to later on:
She seems, well, frazzled... This could've been a result of many occurrences of having her memory wiped.
I mean, after witnessing another one of Gideon's tantrums, she kept muttering "Just keep vacuuming, just keep vacuuming..." to herself.
But why would she need to have her memory wiped?
I'd say from teenage years to late 20s/early 30s? Quite a while.
It's highly possible that during this time, Stan was into the paranormal the way he is now. And since Stan and Carla were so close... Who's to say that Carla didn't know about the happenings of Gravity Falls as well?
If Carla knew about the journals and the strange things that went on in Gravity Falls, it would be a very good reason behind why she would have her memory wiped by the Blindeye Society... And a good explanation for how Gideon obtained the journal.
The show never explained how Gideon got the 2nd journal, so it's really up to interpretation. For the purpose of this theory, I speculate that he received the journal from his mother (or at least through his mother), due to her possible knowledge of the journals because of her close relationship with Stan.
And that's my theory! Bam whaattt. If you ever need me to delve deeper into any more theories Willow, let me know! This was a ton of fun! // kimiko hope
"The codes. There is codes at the end of every show in which is creepy also the slender man thing is fake. I'm thinking bill an Stan are like universal brothers" -Submitted by matthew oblander
Haha yep, slenderman was photoshopped! And the codes at the end of each episode are a reason why I love this show so much. Decodings from season one can be found here and here! I haven't done a season two decoding post yet... I should really get on that.
Oo, and Bill and Stan being universal brothers? I don't really see what you mean, do you think you can give me some more detail?
// kimiko hope
"Alright well raijo is not my real name(as you might have thought). But my theory to all this is that the writer of these books is the man known as: Dipper pines. I say that he came from the future in order to leave the journals in places where they are destined to be found and he knows where to put them because he already lived his life figuring out the mysteries of gravity falls and so dipper as an adult(I imagine) goes to the past to ensure that what should happen to his young self does happen. So whatever does happen is meant to happen so says dipper due to the journals having still been placed where they are. All that's left is to find out what this machine of such holiness does. It couldn't be so bad since dipper approves of its construction so much that he would leave a journal for Stan. All I know is that soon, we will all know what its for and it is important to mankind that Stan goes through with it. As for Stans twin, idk what to he would have to do with all this but perhaps he is dippers co worker in the process of building the machine in the past and this is just a stretch but the six fingers on the journals could merely be symbolic meaning there are six factors or parts to one big thing. Oh and mcgucket is definitely the coworker of the author but which was confirmed in the "society of the blindeye" episode. So he must have been working with dipper before dipper met Stans twin. Oh and since stanford has a twin and is dippers uncle, then either stanley is dippers dad or there were three brothers as siblings. On another note. WHO's to say Stanford isn't their dad in the first place. All I know is that we have never seen the face of dippers dad so we don't know if he is Stanley or not. Hm... Well I think I've written enough for now. You think on it and get back to me on this theory if u like it. It seems pretty solid to me. Anyway bye :) " -Submitted by raijo broloachi
First things first:
I just wanna say that regardless of the fact that it isn't your real name, Raijo is still a pretty rad name. Props to you man for thinking that name up!
My mind has exploded, I had to read this over twice to get all of that info in. Nice theory!!
I just want to make sure I'm getting this right: you're saying that Dipper wrote the journals himself, then in the future, left them for his younger self. This ensures that whatever happened that summer will happen still. Future!Dipper also leaves a journal for Stan on purpose.
And the six fingers being symbolic of six big factors? I haven't heard that before! That's so creative, everyone has been assuming that this meant that the author actually had six fingers! *boosh mind explosion*
The only thing here is that Stanford can't be the twins' dad. "Grunkle" stands for "Great Uncle" meaning that Stanford is the uncle of the twins' dad. (But since he's an uncle he has to have a sibling... #stanleytheory)
All in all, solid theory! I personally definitely think there will be at least one more episode dealing with time traveling/time in general, since Dipper still has Blendin Blandin's time device.
Thanks for submitting man! If you ever think of more theories or expand on this one, make sure to send it in! I'd love to read it! // kimiko hope
"so, I was on the Gravity Falls Wiki after seeing the 'society of a blind eye' episode and found out there is an unaired pilot that Alex Hirsch was asked to make to submit to the board for a review. in this episode, the 'StanLY vs StanFERD' argument started bumpin around in my head because of the way that the pre first season Stan looks. he isn't referred to as 'Grunkle' Stan but as Stan and this Stan is drawn noticeably differently while wearing glasses that are often talked about in the fandom as the 'Stanly glasses' (i.e the ones Stanferd picks up off the table in the carpet episode). if you want, here's a link to screenshots of that episode and you can find clips of it all over the interwebz... http://gravityfalls.wikia.com/wiki/Unaired_pilot just a couple thoughts that may interest you... have a lovely day <3 " -Submitted by Kaoru Lilliehook
Let me just get this off my chest, I smiled when reading this, and I don't know why! Maybe it's because you sound like a really sweet person, or maybe it was the chocolate I just had. Who knows?
Wow, the art style is so different! I'm glad Alex decided to go with the current art style. I love the show's style now! However, I would like to point out that Stan is referred to as "Grunkle" Stan once though, as seen in this clip. But the glasses thing...
Why is he wearing the 'Stanley glasses'?? That's a bit strange! It may be because the show was still under the works, but it's still a bit out of place? I don't know, it's weird.
Okay, while in the middle of writing this post, I took a break and went on tumblr, and I found this:
I remember seeing the whole thing before, and I believe it was possible ways that the characters were going to be introduced in the pilot. But the one line in particular... "I'm... I'm probably you're uncle."
Interpret it how you want, but oh my triangle demons. What does it mean??
Thank you for sharing Kaoru (love your name by the way)! It was interesting to see the pilot, and I hope you have a lovely day as well! <3 // kimiko hope
Note: I am really regretting not posting some of these submissions, but still! This question was sent in before Society of the Blindeye aired, and this post was written prior to the episode as well. I'm posting this anyway because who knows, it may spark a theory of your own!
Ever since the series began, you could tell that Old Man McGucket was a strange man.
In The Legend of the Gobblewonker, it was shown that he built giant (evil?) robots:
Hey there Anony! Thank you for submitting! [I am so sorry for this late response, I intended to respond a lot sooner...]
Since usually I compile theories from other blogs, this will be my first time doing it on my own! Regardless of that, I hope you enjoy.~
*squeals from excitement* Let's get started!
"Hey! I was wondering if you'd do a post on the Old Man McGucket theory. You know, the one where he's the author. Please, please, please write one up!" - Anony Mous
It was this point where it was revealed that the "Gobblewonker" that Dipper and Mabel chased was actually just another one of his creations, and that it was all a lie...
But does that mean that the existence of the Gobblewonker itself was a lie as well? The answer is no.
At the end of the episode, for a mere five seconds, the (assumed to be) real Gobblewonker is shown eating a fallen camera. You can tell that this is the real Gobblewonker for it is more detailed than the robot, and its eyes are not glowing.
Well what point are you trying to make, Kimiko? I'm glad you asked!
Although the robot was not an exact replica of the monster, it was certainly realistic enough to pass as the legitimate thing.
Even Gideon himself knew of McGucket's abilities, and requested for him to create an enormous, high-tech robot replica of him in the episode Gideon Rises.
This leads me to believe that the 'Gobblewonker' Old Man McGucket created was not a spawn of his insanity, but based on something he has seen before. How else would he be able to create something so close to the real thing?
In Headhunters, Mabel creates a wax figurine of Grunkle Stan. As she takes questions after Grunkle Stan presents the 'Eighth Wonder of the World' at the reopening of the wax museum, Old Man McGucket is the first to stand up.
Here, he asks, "Old Man McGucket, local kook. Are the wax figures alive? And, follow-up question, can I survive the wax man uprising?"
A little weird, don't you think? Doesn't it seem like he knows?
After all, from this, it really seems like Old Man McGucket knows about the weird happenings in the town.
If this is true, then why isn't he serious about it? Why doesn't he try to pass off as a normal citizen of the town, like Stan is? He is so strange- completely mad and insane.
Almost as if he went mad and insane.
I mean, in Fight Fighters he was playing the arcade game when it wasn't on (for seven days straight, might I add!) and he does not even live in a house- his home is literally the dump (which is where Dipper finds out about his strange 'car science lab').
We don't know how long he has been like this, but since he calls himself the 'local kook' we can assume that it has been for a long time. Maybe even a good... 30 years.
'Thirty years' is a big part of the show and has been mentioned several times.
It is first mentioned in Scary-oke, where Stan says: "Thirty long years, and it's all led up to this: my greatest achievement! Probably should've worn pants."
It is also brought up by the Shape Shifter, who after Dipper asks what he did to the author, he responds, "You'll likely never find out. That six-fingered nerd hasn't been himself in thirty years! But I thank you for bringing me his journal. He used to write it while I was in my cage..."
'Hasn't been himself in thirty years'? This shows that something happened thirty years ago- the author was himself, before. Until what ever mysterious event took place that drove him mad.
What exactly could have happened? This might be a long-shot, but I have an idea... But before I tell you, let me remind you of the code from the end of season one.
To decipher this code, you use a Combined Cipher: a mix of two or more ciphers seen in the show. It's solved by switching the letters using A1Z26 cipher, then flipping it with the Atbash cryptogram, and finally by using the Caesar cryptogram.
Once it's been decoded, it says, "SEARCH FOR THE BLINDEYE".
After seeing the finale, I speculated that this 'Blindeye' may be Stan, because he wears an eye patch. But one day, I was on tumblr and someone noted that more often than not, Old Man McGucket's eyes aren't completely straight- which may be because one eye is glass.
Remember when Bill inhabited Dipper's body?
He said, "Man, it has been so long since I've inhabited a body... And two eyes? This thing's deluxe!"
What am I trying to get at here? I think Bill possessed Old Man McGucket at one point.
Thirty years ago (which is quite a long time ago, I might add), something happened- maybe something got taken too far, and Bill invaded his mind and took over his body. And if it's true that one of McGucket's eyes is glass... That would certainly explain the 'And two eyes? This thing's deluxe' thing he said.
If Bill possessed him, this may have been the root of his insanity. The author himself wrote to 'NEVER LET HIM INTO YOUR MIND', after all.
But there is something I haven't touched upon yet- Old Man McGucket's hand. Why is it bandaged?
McGucket is one of the several characters (along with Stan and Soos) that have five fingers. The author is assumed to have six. And let me just remind you that the pages mentioning Bill have blood on them...
Maybe he cut off one of his fingers, to hide his identity as the author.
Additionally, to further prove this theory, the laptop Dipper found had a certain initial on it:
...Old Man McGucket's full name is Fiddleford H. McGucket.
Aaaaand there may or may not also be a leaked photo (oh yeah there is a leaked photo). It leaked sometime in 2013, and shows that McGucket is the author, which is where a lot of Fallers originate the theory from!
Thank you for submitting, Anony! I had a ton of fun writing this up. If you ever need another theory, just send it in! :) // kimiko hope
pictures come from http://gravityfalls.wikia.com, theory is my own!
Note: These were submitted before Society of the Blindeye aired (and this post was written around that time as well)!
Since both of these submissions are similar, I'm gonna do it all in one post! Anonymous and greeneggs submitted:
"I have two things to say one the author of the books is old man mcgrunket (not ute in spelling) this is not a theory there was an image leaked between the seasons showing him with an unharmed arm writing one of the three journals when he was younger. The other is a partial fact and theory of the viper wheel the people on it are Stan(claw), soos(?), maybel(shooting star), dipper(pine) these and the author we know are on it for sure. The others are Robbie(heart), Pacifica(llama) based on circulating theories. Stans brother (glasses), lastly Wendy as the ice" - Submitted by Anonymous
First off, thank you for submitting!
I do know about the leaked image, actually! For those who don't know, the following image was leaked (if I can remember correctly) sometime during 2013....
"what about the author of the books ? who might it be ? = theeiry old man mcucckins" - Submitted by greeneggs
And it shows that Old Man McGucket is indeed, the author! Whether this is legit or not is unknown, but it appears to be real. (EDIT: It's fake, as proven in the episode Society of the Blindeye)
A lot of people have been making the connection that the people in the wheel represent characters! This is further proven in Dreamscaperers, when Bill refers to Soos, Dipper, and Mabel as their respective symbols when he says, "Question Mark, Shooting Star, Pine Tree. I had a hunch I'd run into you!".
If you want more insight on the symbols theory, click here! // kimiko hope
fiction > reality
i'm telling you, i'm not obsessed i'm dedicated
warning: there may be spoilers!!
Have something you want me to blog about? Want to request it, or recommend something completely new to me? Feel free to hit that button below!
(Responses can be found under the tag "Ask Time!")
fandoms + tags
good luck charlie
gravity falls: decoded
gravity falls: theories
recs and reviews
the fandom dictionary
where to watch (w2w)